chicks with dicks, just can't stand it.
Oh and to huge dicks and/or breasts. 90% when there is a mom in an incest game, she has bigger boobs than Lolo Ferarri. It's just not immersive at all and also I'm just not a gig fan of big boobs either. The worst was some new game where the sister (about 18) has boobs as big as if she would fall over. What's the point with that. Sisters should be petite, no 18yo looks like that.
Well-guided sandbox is fine, mild grinding is fine. Both together, especially when a lot of time is wasted clicking aimlessly to find an event or having to view the same event a ton of times to get progress, kills it.
I think the most worst thing for a game is the language ur character uses like it depends, it should not simply be sharp it should create tension between characters especially in an incest game like there needs to be a reason that tension grew too strong that it had to break
For me first and foremost is lack of sincerity.
Game could be bad objectively, but you feel the idea author tried to show you on some mental/soul level and brain create additional content by itself. If game HQ by itself - you meet the Masterpiece
Second one is many LI and no harem or at least some group activities. It's worser than unavoidable ntr
Needless exploration sections. Over descripting stuff. Extreme dramas. Trying to make some events 'realistic' but resulting in more immersion-breaking stuff, especially for incest.
I just can't get into NTR games, but the frustrating thing is that they somehow always have the best art/scenes. This is also true for femMC, which is also not ideal for me, although this may be controversial
There's very little that turns me off a game, and I mean very little. Gay adult male stuff just really isn't my thing, so I don't really play them. Hairy stuff just isn't my flavor either. But I tend to decline those options or just not play the game.
I think the only thing that really turns me off is performatively fetishizing minority groups. Autistic, handicapped, etc. I find it super gross.