And I called it a semi-fail-state, or "faux game over," because you're not romancing them then, you're getting a one night stand and missing points and scenes with the only girl that matters and are being, for lack of a better term, railroaded into losing those other girls so why even bother?
I hate sex scenes just to have sex scenes that mean nothing, or worse are a wrong choice in the story and lead to bad ends. And if it's all false choices, especially since you say they are a "romance path," that implies more than a one night stand, I'd just as soon not have those choices at all since it isn't even real. Giving those choices and calling them romance paths makes it seems like they will matter beyond the impact they have on Riley. Maybe label the right choice "focus on [cora's name] romance path" and the wrong one, "lose points with [cora's name] but get a one night stand with this random chick you'll lose and never see again," so it is clear that this is the way the story is intended and will go no matter what choice we pick. (Edit: obviously you'd want to streamline those labels, lol)
Because I assumed that, since they were called romance paths that they would circle back and the girl would show up again possible. I, maybe foolishly, assumed that choices would matter or why bother having them. That maybe there was an outcome where you could have just a father/daughter relationship with Riley and could end up with one (or more) of the other ladies as mother for her and be a more normal (to some extent) family. Or maybe it would turn out that the magic stuff was more real than the Mc believes and there really was a greater force at work and it was kind of setting up him and Riley to meet these woman that also needed what Riley does, but never got it, but get it from him (a stable guardian/dad figure) and so that was were it was going. Or, especially with Jade, these other relationships would help him realize that he really wants Riley as more than a daughter and maybe one, or more, of the other ladies saying/doing things that make Riley see herself and him in a more sexual light than she seems to as time goes on so it all builds to them getting together with some (maybe not all) helping it along.
Or maybe, since Mc and Riley are on the move, they could end up at that store again, if you romance Amy. If you romance Raven then she sees the vision as her being meant to serve you as like a breeding live stock almost, a little crazy, but not dangerously so especially not out of no where if you pick her "romance" path since that is kind of the vibe she gives during the sex scene. But if you're basically forced to be with Riley and every other girls is just a poor excuse for sex scenes, then I can't help but wonder why bother with other chicks at all? Why not just tell the story of Mc and Riley on the move and have the other chicks be back ground characters?
And, also, them being "on the move" seems weird too. He's retired and she is nobody, just a nameless girl and outside of his home town where he might run into someone he knows, literally everyone would just assume he is her father if that's what he says because that's how a real father and a daughter travel. It's not like a father carries his daughter's paperwork around when they travel or his license says he's a single man with no kids. So why is he acting like he's on the run with people coming after him? I thought the idea was for them to travel a bit and find a place to settle down and start over, which is what, if I recall correctly, the Mc thoughts said in the first part. Go somewhere new, start over. Which is also why I assumed that the romance paths were actual romance paths, because we would be settling in that new area, meeting girls there and building the main relationship with Riley. But instead he's acting like they are running from the mob or other cops or something, giving fake names and paying with cash. No person they meet is going to know your name on your license doesn't match the one you gave them, outside of like a landlord or something, but you could give them your real name and just tell them, I go by [fake name], and they wouldn't really care. It just feels like the "stay on the move," is going to be used as an excuse for why none of the other ladies, and none of the other choices, matter. So, again, why have them?
Anyway, that's all I've got really. Sorry it's a bit rambling, but I really liked the concept and Riley and Jade too. While I'm willing to take some of the blame (for lack of a better term) for my expectation and assumptions I find it hard to take all of it. Because I based those assumptions and expectations on the clues and story you presented in the game. For example; calling it "Jade Romance Path," Jade and Riley being so similar and getting so close so quickly, the concept being presented that they were just looking for a new place to settle down so they weren't going to be on the run like a pair of fugitives, him referencing and using his connections meaning he hasn't even left his past fully behind like someone actually on the run, the pseudo-magic stuff going on maybe hinting at something more going on, and even a few other things.
So, all that said, if this really is a solo-girl game, with a forced solo-girl but a bunch of other chicks in the way with false choices, then I'm not sure I'll be sticking around for this one update-to-update anymore. Might come back when it is done. I wish you the best and success, but I'm not a fan of games like that (Edit: pseudo-harem games where every girls around wants to bang Mc but if he does it then bad things happen of we miss the main point of the story, just make a solo-girl game if that's what you want it to be) if that is where the game is going.
EDIT: If I'm making another wrong assumption here, and it is real romances that we will get to revisit and have more content with and possible get more out of then fair enough. I'd be willing to be corrected.