I can usually overlook one of the two being less than great if the other is good enough to make up for it, though with both the art and the writing there is a level at which it's so bad that no matter how good the other half is I find I can't really enjoy the experience, and I just put it down and go do something else.
both are somewhat important, played wife trainer wich was awesome and some other html games with almost no graphics and had a blast... but i do enjoy some renpy and nice graphics too ... i think both have their place here
It feels a little like asking milk or cereal? Gotta be both. Just like with women...she gotta make my pee pee hard and be fun to talk to, otherwise she'll get boring fast.
Both of you're right to some extent
But there's more dynamics to enjoying the game. There's Music, Sounds & Animations, and then there's Graphics and Plot which makes the game different from porn.
If there's a lot of naration & dialogue, then the fun is spoilt!
tough question, and tbh i'm not persistent over this. what i mean is, sometimes i choose the plot sometimes i choose the graphics and sometimes it's both.