discussion Hand Drawn vs 3D vs Pixel art, which one is your favorite?

[User_11475]

Hand-drawing allows the artist to have a generally more pronounced style, and therefore a greater diversity of game visuals.

You must be registered to see attachments

here from This Romantic World by reinbachart

 

[jedichip]

true plus rooms in the building and nature always detailed and actually beautiful.. never thought about it that way.. thank you as always

 

[Axelino1999]

I love both 3d and hand draw, the first for the realism and the other for the details and the unique touches and personality of every artist. I do not like pixel art sadly.

 

[User_107292]

Pixels are my favorite just because good ones are so rare.

 

[Conan]

I don't have any special preferences, I like 2d and 3d, sometimes pixel ones. But I will say one thing, when I first got acquainted with porn games, I was interested in 2d art games, because at that time 3d was at a low level and all the models were almost the same.

 

[User_48178]

Hand drawn is hit or miss. Some of it's great, and some is hideous. There's also a lot that use the same style as Good Girl Gone Bad and I've grown to hate that style. It always looked a little off to me, and being everywhere now I can't stand seeing it.

Pixel art is hard to make sexy. It's been done but rarely very well.

3D is the best bet for consistently hot images created by amateurs.

 

[HaloSkull]

2DCG is the winner for me.

 

[User_95020]

Each of them got their own charm. I like 3d the most tho.

 

[User_101810]

All three can be done well, in my opinion

 

[KeelOver]

I feel out of place, 3D is usually something I am turned off by no matter how hard I try. I think its a mix of the uncannyness I get from it

 

[TheVampirate]

With the 3D, as the technology advances I think it's doesn"t matter what program was used, most games will look bad when you compare with the "new version"

It's like when you played those PS2/Xbox games and you got impressed with how realistic it was, but today they look like shit

I look back at PS2 games and am surprised by how good they hold up games haven't gotten as much of a glow up in like 10 years. the difference between each generation from ps1 to ps3 was pretty big and at least doubled the difference between PS3 and PS5 to me feels much less than the jump from PS2 to PS3. PC is similar and unless you start seeing games made in new engines there's not going to be much better quality in 5+ years. The artists matter more than the hardware most of the time in these games while professionally made games what often matters most is how much money is spent on the project and can your rig play the games well enough to get the game running smoothly with whatever graphic settings you have on.

 

[Loliholic]

I dont care about the source of art, i can enjoy hs and koi as much as drawn, daz'ed or ai. I also can hate oll of them. In the end its just about my personal taste in woman, those who get it into a npc get a fan, those who fail dont get one.
However, i never saw any appeal in pixel art, thats just as annoying as censored porn.

 

[tyktamsyl]

I like them all, but i’ve only ever found one pixel art game that I’ve liked a lot (Hero Party Must Fall). I guess my favorite is 2D hand drawn.

 

[Taro]

Of course it's 3D but pixels have perspective

 

[Jgergergerger]

3D mostly for me

 

[Sarmen]

Hand drawn>Pixel>3D

 

[HZeroH]

when i started i only played 2d games. but lately i play more 3d game, i guess thats because the sheer quantity of 3dcg games being made.

 

[zagreus]

I would love to see a good western pixel art game that doen't involve monster porn. All i have seen is are tentacle/monster rape porn games

 

[User_98760]

Nothing else but 3d art, pixel porn game is a joke actually

 

[Deleted member 108320]

I usually prefer Hand drawn.